Classic Italian · Hampton Bays
Handmade pastas, slow-braised ragùs, and candlelit tables — Villa Paul brings the warmth of an Italian family kitchen to Montauk Highway.
What We Do
Handmade pastas, slow-braised ragùs, and candlelit tables — Villa Paul brings the warmth of an Italian family kitchen to Montauk Highway.
Rolled by hand daily — tagliatelle, gnocchi, lasagna — with sauces that simmer for hours.
Learn moreOsso buco, chicken scarpariello, branzino — the classics, done the old way.
Learn moreAnniversaries, rehearsal dinners, family milestones — our private room seats 30.
Learn more* Illustrative figures shown for this design concept.
Before & After
Drag the slider — from the tired dining room we inherited to the warm, candlelit Villa Paul of today.
Dated & DimBefore
Our Candlelit RoomAfter
Our Promise
“The osso buco tastes like someone's nonna is back there — because she probably is. Our anniversary spot, every year.” — Anniversary Guests, Hampton Bays
How It Works
Call for tonight or next month — weekends fill fast, and the private room books out.
Start with burrata and a glass of Chianti while the kitchen works its magic.
Handmade this afternoon, sauced to order. This is what you came for.
Tiramisu and a proper espresso. Linger — that's what the candles are for.
Kind Words
Common Questions
Recommended, especially Friday and Saturday — call (631) 728-3261. Walk-ins are welcome when tables allow.
Yes — gluten-free pasta is available for most dishes, and many secondi are naturally gluten-free. Tell your server.
Our private room seats 30 — ideal for rehearsal dinners, birthdays, and anniversaries. We also cater off-site.
We have a full Italian wine list and bar; corkage is available for special bottles — ask when you book.
Absolutely — families are the heart of an Italian table. Early seatings are best with little ones.
Yes, the full menu is available for takeout. Call ahead and we'll have it hot and ready.
Hampton Bays, NY
Call for tonight's table, the private room, or catering — we'll save you a seat by the candles.